moderated Fw: Question regarding either of these options.


Glenn / Lenny
 

Hi,
I would not lose any sleep over having defragged an SSD, it won't break it if you do that, the truth is, that SSD drives are fast enough that you won't get any benefit from doing that, and your SSD drive has many write cycles to it, but they are indeed limited, so a few defrags won't hurt and may not help.
But if you have deleted a lot of really really large files, it may help on rare occasions.
Just don't be scared if you do this, thinking that it would help and worried that it may hurt the drive, it likely didn't hurt anything.
Here is how it is described by Crucial.com, who sells disk drives:

Should You Defrag an SSD?
 
If you’ve ever owned a traditional hard drive, you have probably defragged it at some point along the way. This is because defragging a hard drive is necessary
due to the way it is built. In recent years, many people have been replacing their HDD with an SSD due to the impressive
technology
 and additional
benefits.
Those who are used to defragging their hard drives may wonder if it is necessary to defrag an SSD. We answer that question below.
 
Should I defrag my SSD?
 
The short answer is this: you don't have to defrag an SSD.
 
To understand why, we first need to look at the purpose of defragmenting a drive. Defragging ensures that large files are stored in one continuous area
of a hard disk drive so that the file can be read in one go. Mechanical drives have a relatively long seek time of approximately 15ms, so every time a
file is fragmented you lose 15ms finding the next one. This really adds up when reading lots of different files split into lots of different fragments.
However, this isn't an issue with SSDs because the seek time are about 0.1ms. You won’t really notice the benefit of defragged files — which means there
is no performance advantage to defragging an SSD.
 
SSDs move data that's already on your disk to other places on your disk, often sticking it at a temporary position first. That's what gives defragmenting
a disadvantage for SSD users. You’re writing data you already have, which uses up some of the NAND's limited rewrite capability. So, you get no performance
advantage whatsoever, but you are using up some of the limited rewrite capability.
 
To summarize, do not defrag an SSD
 
The answer is short and simple — do not defrag a solid state drive. At best it won't do anything, at worst it does nothing for your performance and you
will use up write cycles. If you have done it a few times, it isn't going to cause you much trouble or harm your SSD. You just don’t want this to be a
scheduled, weekly type thing that takes away from the finite number of SSD rewrites. There are other ways to
clean up and increase speed
 on your computer. There are even reasons for
formatting an SSD,
encrypting SSDs,
and ways to
increase storage space on a SSD.
They all serve a purpose — there just isn’t a reason to defrag an SSD.

----- Original Message -----
Sent: Monday, March 29, 2021 12:48 PM
Subject: Re: Question regarding either of these options.

Albert,
You will always want to do a disk cleanup first, then do a defrag.
The disk cleanup will make space that the defrag will write data onto to make a tighter usage of the disk.
Glenn
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Monday, March 29, 2021 12:38 PM
Subject: Question regarding either of these options.

Good afternoon everyone, 

 

Does windows ten, have a utility built into it that will automatically do both a disk defrag, and a disk cleanup on a weekly schedule, or do you have too do it yourself?  If not, which one do you have too do first.  In other words, should I do a disk  defrag first, and then do a disk cleanup second 

 

Thanks in advance, 

 

Al   ? Which one comes first.